Click here for a listing of our upcoming auctions On Line Absentee Form		Session #4 Sunday, November 11, 2007 (Sale begins at 10:00 a.m. with Lot #2001) Lots #2301 - #2405 Lee/Rose Nos. 523 - 843 Auction Terms Click on this link to return to the November 9 - 11 Main Page. Links to the other online catalog sessions, Catalog Terms and Terms of Sale, etc. can be found there. Lot 2301 - LEE/ROSE NO. 523-A , yellow green, 62 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, Bilane recorded only one example. Probably very or extremely rare. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/16" d. Proof. Estimate: $150 - $250. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Lot 2302 - LEE/ROSE NO. 524 , amethyst, 44 even scallops. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/16" d. Above average condition, one scallop tipped and three others lightly tipped, one small top-rim spall and two minor flakes. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/26/89, lot #409, $148. Lot 2303 - LEE/ROSE NO. 524 , blue, 44 even scallops. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/16" d. Average condition, several scallops tipped and numerous lightly tipped, some top-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Provenance: James H. Rose, 9/68, $35. Lot 2304 - LEE/ROSE NO. 530 , brownish amethyst, slightly translucent, 65 even scallops. Rare or very rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Loss of two scallops and four others tipped, small top-rim chip and several flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1407. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/19/89, lot #253, $71. Ex-coll: Yaeger Family. Lot 2305 - LEE/ROSE NO. 530 , dark blue, 65 even scallops. Scarce. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Three scallops tipped and three others lightly tipped, some minor top-rim flakes/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1407. Lot 2306 - LEE/ROSE NO. 531 , yellow green, 34 bull's-eye scallops. Rare. Midwestern. 3 5/8" d. Near proof having only two very lightly tipped scallops and some very minor top-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1414. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/69, $45. Lot 2307 - LEE/ROSE NO. 531 , bright medium green, 34 bull's-eye scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, Bilane recorded only one example. Midwestern. 3 5/8" d. Well above average condition, one lightly tipped scallop and two others very lightly tipped, one small light top-rim spall and several minor flakes. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Provenance: James H. Rose, 5/70, $45. Lot 2308 - LEE/ROSE NO. 535 , colorless, plain rim. Extremely rare. Probably Curling's Ft. Pitt Works. 3 11/16" d. Near proof having only four small light top-rim flakes and a hint of mold roughness, profile is proof. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Bilane, p. 29. Elsholz, lot #1394, this being the actual example. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1394, $150. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 6/25/69. Ex-coll: Frank W. Davis. Note: This is the first example of this plate that we have sold. Lot 2309 - LEE/ROSE NO. 541 , colorless, 60 even scallops. Very rare. Probably Midwestern. 3 1/8" d. Well above average having only the loss of one scallop and one other tipped, otherwise only some light mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/19/89, lot #117, $27. Ex-coll: Yaeger Family. Note: This is the first example of this plate that we have sold and the only example recorded by Mrs. Powell. Lot 2310 - LEE/ROSE NO. 548 , colorless, 18 large scallops with smaller pairs of scallops between. Very rare. Unknown origin. 3 1/2" d. Virtually proof having only a lightly tipped small scallop and two minute top-rim flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 6/10/81, lot #232, $90. Ex-coll: Mrs. E. A. "Sue" Hawkes. Lot 2311 - LEE/ROSE NO. 550 , fiery opalescent, 53 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, Bilane recorded only one example. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Proof. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Bilane, p. 30. B & K I, fig. 1411, being the example recorded by Bilane. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 8/23/94, lot #301, $110, miscataloged as L/R No. 549. Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Lot 2312 - LEE/ROSE NO. 561 , colorless, octagonal with seven even scallops between corners, light rivet head in center. Very rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Above average condition, loss of one corner and one edge scallop, another side scallop tipped, one small top-rim chip, several flakes and light mold roughness. Estimate: $500 - $800. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1467, which was exhibited at the Henry Ford Museum in 1960. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 171, fig. 1, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Miami Beach Show, 2/78, $500. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #653) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list where he described it as extremely rare. Lot 2313 - LEE/ROSE NO. 562 , colorless, embossed "Henry Clay", 18 large scallops with smaller pairs between. Very rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Proof except for some very minor under-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1469. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 171, fig. 12, "100 Best" clear. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1412. Provenance: Abraham & May, 2/69, $112. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #638) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2314 - LEE/ROSE NO. 562-A-X-1 , colorless, embossed "Henry Clay", variation with higher arc scallops, 49 even scallops. Unknown rarity. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 3/8" d. Near proof, one tipped scallop, normal under-rim flaking/mold roughness, chip to table ring. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Bilane, p. 31. Elsholz, lot #1470. B & K I, fig. 1412. Provenance: James H. Rose, 11/70, $54. Lot 2315 - LEE/ROSE NO. 564 , dark blue, 25 large scallops with smaller pairs between. Plentiful. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 5/8" d. Above average condition, partial loss of one large scallop, another tipped and two others lightly tipped, several minor top-rim flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Abraham & May, 9/73, $54. Lot 2316 - LEE/ROSE NO. 565-B , blue, 51 even scallops. Scarce. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Above average condition, loss of one scallop, partial loss of another, and two others lightly tipped, flake to table ring. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Parallels B & K I, fig. 1413. Spillman, fig. 420. Provenance: James H. Rose, 10/72, $55. Lot 2317 - LEE/ROSE NO. 565-B , brilliant peacock blue, 51 even scallops. Scarce. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Average condition, partial loss of one scallop, four others lightly tipped, small top-rim spall and several minor flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: B & K I, fig. 1413. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/69, $37. Lot 2318 - LEE/ROSE NO. 575 , medium blue, 25 large scallops with smaller pairs between, fire polished rim. Unrecorded in AGCP, color listed by Bilane. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for the loss of one large scallop and two flakes to table ring. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Bilane, p. 32. Elsholz, lot #1417, this being the actual example. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1417, $325. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 5/18/75. Ex-coll: Mrs. Harry S. High. Note: This is the first example of this plate that we have sold. Lot 2319 - LEE/ROSE NO. 576 , medium blue, 25 large scallops with smaller pairs between. Extremely rare. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Above average condition, one large scallop tipped and two others lightly tipped, loss of one small scallop, several small top-rim flakes. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1419. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 181, fig. 29a, "100 Best" colored. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1415. Parallels Spillman, fig. 422. Provenance: Abraham & May, 2/69, $175. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #589) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2320 - LEE/ROSE NO. 580 , colorless, 56 even scallops. Extremely rare. English. 3 3/4" d. Partial loss of three scallops and several others tipped, two under-rim spalls. Estimate: $75 - $125. Provenance: Guernsey, 10/69. Lot 2321 - LEE/ROSE NO. 580-B , colorless, 58 even scallops. Extremely rare. English. 3 7/8" d. Near proof having only one tipped and another lightly tipped scallop. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Bilane, p. 32. Provenance: James H. Rose, 1972, $80. Lot 2322 - LEE/ROSE NO. 585 , colorless, embossed "Ringgold Palo Alto", 72 even scallops. Very rare. Philadelphia area, possibly Union Glass Works. 3 3/8" d. Rim chip erasing one scallop, partial loss of three other scallops and several additional tipped, area of underfill and partial fin. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1481. Provenance: James H. Rose, 11/70, $120. Note: Rose noted "The usual specimen is badly battered." Lot 2323 - LEE/ROSE NO. 585-A , colorless, embossed "Ringgold Palo Alto", 12 large scallops with four smaller between. Extremely rare. Philadelphia area, possibly Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. Well above average condition, loss of one large and one small scallop, several other scallops tipped or lightly tipped. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1482. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 173, fig. 23, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 11/20/85, lot #69, $450. Ex-coll: Larry Gray Fair & Elry M. Groves. David & Linda Arman. Ex-coll: Caleb C. Ewing. Ex-coll: Mr. & Mrs. Leon Neefe. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #641) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2324 - LEE/ROSE NO. 585-C , colorless, embossed "Ringgold Palo Alto", 18 large scallops with smaller scallop and two points between. Very rare. Philadelphia area, possibly Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. Above average condition, loss of two small scallops and several points, one large scallop very lightly tipped and three with slight underfill. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1483. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 173, fig. 28, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Myer, 9/69, $30. Lot 2325 - LEE/ROSE NO. 586-A , colorless, embossed "Ringgold. Palo Alto", 12 large scallops with four smaller ones between. Extremely rare. Philadelphia area, possibly Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. Poor condition with numerous rim chips and losses to scallops. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1484. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/9/86, lot #295, $325. Ex-coll: Dr. Grace O. Doane. Lot 2326 - LEE/ROSE NO. 586-B , colorless, embossed "Ringgold. Palo Alto", 18 large scallops with smaller scallop and two points between. Extremely rare. Philadelphia area, possibly Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. Unbelievably proof with a spot of mold roughness to a slight fin, best possible example. Estimate: $500 - $800. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1485. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 173, fig. 25, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 11/20/85, lot #70, $605. Ex-coll: Larry Gray Fair & Elry M. Groves. Arlene Gade. Note: AGCP notes "Stippled-type Ringgolds are, in general, even rarer than the variety with plain background. Proof specimens are virtually unobtainable." An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #644) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2327 - LEE/ROSE NO. 591 , colorless, 48 even scallops. Very rare. Eastern, probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Above average condition, partial loss of one scallop and several others lightly tipped. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1402. Provenance: James H. Rose, 1972, $100. Lot 2328 - LEE/ROSE NO. 592 , colorless, 21 large scallops with single smaller between. Extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Usual poor condition with the loss of three large scallops, flaking, and a large top-rim spall. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1403. B & K I, fig. 1416. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 171, fig. 11, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Richard H. Wood, 8/69, $75. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #645) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. AGCP notes "usually lacks a serration or two." Lot 2329 - LEE/ROSE NO. 594 , amber, 66 even scallops. Rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/4" d. Well above average condition, partial loss of one scallop, two others lightly tipped, and another very lightly tipped, one minute top-rim flake, slightly warped. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1422. B & K I, fig. 1417. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 186, fig. 9, "100 Best" colored. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 6/10/81, lot #371, $350. Ex-coll: Mrs. E. A. "Sue" Hawkes. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #592) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2330 - LEE/ROSE NO. 595 , opalescent, 66 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, Bilane recorded only one example. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 5/16" d. Under-rim spall erasing one scallop, partial loss of another scallop, otherwise proof. Estimate: $300 - $500. Reference: Bilane, p. 32. Elsholz, lot #1405, this being the actual example. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1405, $340. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 6/25/69. Ex-coll: James P. McGowan, Jr. Ex-coll: Frank W. Davis. Lot 2331 - LEE/ROSE NO. 600 , colorless, 72 even scallops. Extremely rare, Elsholz's notes indicate only two known. Philadelphia area, probably Union Glass Works. 3 3/8" d. Loss of one scallop and partial loss of three others, one additional very lightly tipped, otherwise proof. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1588, this being the actual example. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 7/17/01, lot #33, $1,870. Ex-coll: Eugenie Philbrick. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1588, $400. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 6/11/63. Note: An important plate with impeccable provenance. It is superior in condition to Marble's example illustrated in AGCP and the Bilane specimen sold through our galleries in 2004. Lot 2332 - LEE/ROSE NO. 600-B , colorless, nine pairs of large scallops with four smaller ones between. Unique. Philadelphia area, probably Union Glass Works. 3 3/8" d. Poor condition with multiple chips erasing numerous scallops. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Bilane, p. 32. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 7/17/01, lot #32, $990. Ex-coll: Eugenie Philbrick. Ex-coll: Dr. Grace O. Doane. Ex-coll: George C. Cannon. Note: A very important plate despite its condition issues. It was on both Marble's and Elsholz's want lists but neither acquired a specimen. This is the very example illustrated in AGCP where Rose stated that there were but two specimens known. Bilane later corrected that statement when he noted that Paul Carson's plate (which went to Marble) turned out to be a L/R No. 600-C, leaving Cannon's (this) plate as the only known example. Lot 2333 - LEE/ROSE NO. 600-C , colorless, 18 large scallops with a smaller scallop and two points between. Extremely rare, Bilane recorded only two examples including this plate. Philadelphia area, probably Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. V-shape chip from rim with an associated 1/2" crack, otherwise only minor mold roughness. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Bilane, p. 32. Provenance: Vermont antiques shop, 1970, $7. Note: A very important plate despite its condition issues. It was on Elsholz's want list but he never acquired a specimen. Lot 2334 - LEE/ROSE NO. 601-C , colorless, 18 large scallops with a smaller scallop and two points between. Extremely rare. Philadelphia area, probably Union Glass Works. 3 7/16" d. Excellent condition for this series, loss of one small scallop, partial loss of two large scallops and another tipped, other flaking and mold roughness. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1590. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 171, fig. 8, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 6/10/97, lot #33, miscataloged as L/R No. 600-C. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #649) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2335 - LEE/ROSE NO. 604-A , colorless, octagonal with seven even scallops between corners. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for one lightly tipped corner and side scallop, and two very lightly tipped corners. Estimate: $30 - $50. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1591. Lot 2336 - LEE/ROSE NO. 605-V-1 , colorless, deep variation with rivet head in center of cavetto, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Extremely rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Near proof for this rim, one tipped point and two scallops, another scallop very lightly tipped, small light top-rim spall and some light flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $800 - $1,200. Reference: Bilane, p. 33. Elsholz, lot #1592, variation not noted. Parallels Spillman, fig. 427. Provenance: James H. Rose, 11/74, $350. Note: An example of the non-variant version of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #656) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2337 - LEE/ROSE NO. 605-A , moonstone/translucent clambroth, octagonal with seven scallops between corners, shallow type. Unrecorded in AGCP, probably extremely rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for one tipped and two very lightly tipped scallops. Estimate: $800 - $1,200. Reference: Bilane, p. 33. Elsholz, lot #1593, this being the actual example. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1593, $900. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 5/21/56. Lot 2338 - LEE/ROSE NO. 605-A-V-1 , colorless, variation with light rivet head in center of cavetto, deep type, octagonal with seven scallops between corners. Scarce or rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Near proof having only two very lightly tipped side scallops and a minor top-rim flake. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 33. Elsholz, lot #1594. Spillman, fig. 428. Lot 2339 - LEE/ROSE NO. 610-A , unrecorded swirling translucent soft blue alabaster with sanded surface, 23 bold scallops with smaller pairs between. Most certainly unique. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 5/8" d. Poor condition, two rim chips erasing multiple scallops, numerous other losses. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Parallels B & K I, fig. 1418. Note: A most important and peculiar plate despite its condition issues. Lot 2340 - LEE/ROSE NO. 610-B , brilliant blue, 25 flat scallops with single point between. Scarce. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Above average for this plate, top-rim spall erasing most of one large scallop, loss of one point and two others tipped. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/69, $28. Note: Rose noted "immaculate specimens are hard to find". Lot 2341 - LEE/ROSE NO. 612-A , colorless, octagonal with seven even scallops between corners. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Near proof, partial loss of one scallop and two others lightly tipped, one extremely light small rim spall. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1599. Provenance: Guernsey, 10/69. Lot 2342 - LEE/ROSE NO. 612-A , unrecorded colorless with silver nitrate/amber staining to shoulder and center, staining of unsubstantiated association, slightly cloudy, octagonal with seven even scallops between corners, tilted. Unknown rarity, probably unique. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Loss of one side scallop, partial loss of one corner and several side scallops. Estimate: $200 - $300. Lot 2343 - LEE/ROSE NO. 614 , colorless, embossed "Union Glass Works, Pittsburgh, PA, 1836", octagonal with six even scallops on each side between corners. Extremely rare. Probably Parke, Campbell and Hanna, Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Pristine proof except for three minute top-rim flakes and a minute flake to table ring, partial slight fin. Estimate: $1,500 - $2,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1600. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 172, fig. 15, "100 Best" clear. Spillman, fig. 431, "Few of these plates are known". Innes, pl. 313. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 10/22/91, lot #129, $3,740. Note: Best possible example of one of the cornerstones of any serious cup plate collection. An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #672) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2344 - LEE/ROSE NO. 615 , colorless, 41 even scallops. Extremely rare, only five or six recorded examples. Uncertain origin. 3 9/16" d. Near proof having only two lightly tipped scallops and two more very lightly tipped. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1601, this being the actual example. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 172, fig. 14, "100 Best" clear. Bilane, p. 33. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 6/13/95, lot #106, $1,760. Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1601, $850. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/9/67. James H. Rose, agent. Ex-coll: John Rollin Stuart, III. Note: An important plate with impeccable provenance and in top condition. Rose noted "Not only is this one of the rarest plates known (we can locate but four copies), but no proof specimen exists." McKearin noted "only 5 specimens known at present and not 1 in proof condition." Bilane updated "Wood had one in proof several years ago." An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #654) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2345 - LEE/ROSE NO. 615-A , colorless, 25 scallops with single point between. Very rare. Uncertain origin. 3 3/8" d. Near proof having only one scallop and two points lightly tipped. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1602. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 172, fig. 13, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Omaha antiques shop, 1966, $20. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #655) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2346 - LEE/ROSE NO. 619 , violet blue, embossed "Benjamin Franklin", 48 even scallops. Extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for one tipped scallop. Estimate: $800 - $1,200. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1424, this being the actual example. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1419. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1424, $625. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Exhibited: Henry Ford Museum, 1960, No. 460. James H. Rose, 12/12/56. Ex-coll: George C. Cannon. Exhibited: Detroit Institute of Arts, 1953. Note: An important plate with unparalleled provenance and in top condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #594) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2347 - LEE/ROSE NO. 619 , translucent clambroth/alabaster with a touch of opalescence, embossed "Benjamin Franklin", 48 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, probably extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Loss of one scallop and two others lightly tipped, otherwise proof. Estimate: $300 - $500. Reference: Bilane, p. 33. Elsholz, lot #1603. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1419. Provenance: James H. Rose, 1968, $125. Note: An example of this plate, cataloged as alabaster, from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #593) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list where it he noted that it was unrecorded. Lot 2348 - LEE/ROSE NO. 619-A , colorless cavetto and scallops with silver nitrate/amber stained shoulder, embossed "Benjamin Franklin", 59 even scallops. Extremely rare, only three or four recorded. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Proof except for one very lightly tipped scallop. Estimate: $3,000 - $5,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1534, cataloged as "Unique," this being the actual example. B & K I, fig. 1420b. Bilane, p. 34. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1534, $3,300. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 8/31/67. Ex-coll: James P. McGowan. Note: An extremely important and desirable plate with impeccable provenance and in the best possible condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #596) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2349 - LEE/ROSE NO. 619-A , colorless with silver nitrate/amber stained cavetto, embossed "Benjamin Franklin", 59 even scallops. Extremely rare, only six recorded. This plate is one of the first two discovered in Maine by Mrs. Whichelow in 1946, one went to Marble and this one went to Dr. Ruff. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Proof except for the partial loss of one scallop. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1533. B & K I, fig. 1420a. Bilane, p. 34. Provenance: Green Valley Auctions, Inc., 5/20/06, lot #623, $3,300. Ex-coll: Dr. Augustine J. Ruff. Note: An extremely important plate in outstanding condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #598) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2350 - LEE/ROSE NO. 619-B , all-over silver nitrate/amber staining with scallops left colorless, embossed "Benjamin Franklin", 57 even scallops. Extremely rare, only three or four recorded. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Near proof having only four very lightly tipped scallops. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1535, this being the actual example. B & K I, fig. 1421. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/17/87, lot #1535, $2,300. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 12/12/56. Ex-coll: George C. Cannon. Note: An extremely important and desirable plate with impeccable provenance and in top condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #597) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2351 - LEE/ROSE NO. 625-B-X , colorless, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", variant with 53 even scallops. Unknown rarity. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Proof with just a hint of mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 34. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/19/89, lot #241, $27, miscataloged as L/R No. 625 Ex-coll: Yaeger Family. Lot 2352 - LEE/ROSE NO. 628 , medium green with smoke striations, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", 38 even scallops. Extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Under-rim chip erasing one scallop, another scallop lightly tipped, otherwise only a single minor top-rim flake. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: B & K I, fig. 1422. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 5/18/74, lot #540, $250. Ex-coll: Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth D. Wakefield. Exhibited: Sandwich Glass Museum. Lot 2353 - LEE/ROSE NO. 628 , light bluish green, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", 38 even scallops. Very rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Under-rim chip erasing two scallops, otherwise only a small underfill and hint of mold roughness. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1734, color miscataloged. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1422. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 5/18/74, lot #539, $110. Ex-coll: Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth D. Wakefield. Exhibited: Sandwich Glass Museum. Lot 2354 - LEE/ROSE NO. 628 , brilliant medium electric blue, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", 38 even scallops. Very rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Loss of one scallop and partial loss of another, otherwise only some mold roughness to table ring. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Parallels B & K I, fig. 1422. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 5/13/87, lot #157, $495. Ex-coll: Eugene E. Smith. Lot 2355 - LEE/ROSE NO. 629 , brilliant medium electric blue, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", 38 even scallops. Very or extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Near proof having only one tipped and several very lightly tipped scallops. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1735, this being the actual example. Bilane, p. 34. B & K I, fig. 1423. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1735, $1,100. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 9/23/68. Ex-coll: Mrs. Leon Bard. Note: This is the first example of this plate that we have sold. Lot 2356 - LEE/ROSE NO. 631 , brilliant deep emerald green, embossed "Chancellor Livingston", 63 even scallops. Extremely rare. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 7/16" d. Above average condition, two scallops tipped and several others lightly tipped, small open bubble at one scallop tip, mold roughness to table ring. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1736, this being the actual example. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 181, fig. 20, "100 Best" colored. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1736, $1,450. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Richard H. Wood, 4/16/62. Note: A very important and beautiful plate with impeccable provenance and in excellent condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #595) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2357 - LEE/ROSE NO. 635 , strong olive green, plain rim. Extremely rare. Probably Midwestern. 3 7/16" d. Near proof having only a hint of top-rim flaking/mold roughness and normal under-rim flaking/mold roughness, rim profile is proof. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1737, this being the actual example. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1737, $1,450. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 12/12/56. Ex-coll: George C. Cannon. Note: A very important plate with impeccable provenance and in top condition. We could locate no additional sales records for this plate. Lot 2358 - LEE/ROSE NO. 636 , light green, plain rim. Scarce. Probably Midwestern. 3 7/16" d. Above average condition, very shallow flake to rim edge which only very slightly affects the profile, several minute top-rim flakes, and normal under-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Guernsey, 11/69, $50. Lot 2359 - LEE/ROSE NO. 641 , canary yellow, 76 even scallops. Very rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Pristine proof except for a very light under-rim flake and a hint of minute mold roughness. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1669, this being the actual example. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1424. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 4/11/95, lot #115, $1,210. Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1669, $750. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Richard H. Wood, 3/16/55. Note: A great plate with impeccable provenance and in the best possible condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #601) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2360 - LEE/ROSE NO. 643 , light opalescent, 53 even scallops. Rare. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 9/16" d. Near proof having only one tipped scallop and a hint of under-rim mold roughness, also with a faint shoulder check which does have dept but does not break the surface. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1671. Provenance: Richard H. Wood, 10/74, $110. Lot 2361 - LEE/ROSE NO. 643-A , medium blue green, 53 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, this very reported by Bilane as unique. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 5/8" d. Proof except for a very lightly tipped scallop and some very minor under-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1738, this being the actual example, miscataloged color. Bilane, p. 35. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1738, $2,100. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/9/67. James H. Rose, agent. Ex-coll: John Rollin Stuart, III. Note: A very important plate with stellar provenance and in the best possible condition. We could locate no additional examples of this plate. Lot 2362 - LEE/ROSE NO. 645-A , brilliant deep emerald green, 53 even scallops. Extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 3/4" d. Proof except for some normal light under-rim flaking/mold roughness and a flake to table ring. Estimate: $1,500 - $2,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1739. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 185, fig. 5, "100 Best" colored. Spillman, fig. 440 and color pl. 6. Parallels B & K I, fig. 1425. Bilane, p. 35. Note: An important and beautiful plate in the best possible condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #602) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2363 - LEE/ROSE NO. 650 , bluish fiery opalescent, plain rope rim, top and bottom. Extremely rare. New England, possibly New England Glass Co. 3 11/16" d. Virtually proof having only two minute flakes to outer rim and several under rim, profile is proof. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1673, this being the actual example. Bilane, p. 35. Parallels McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 174, fig. 30, "100 Best" colored. Parallels Spillman, fig. 442 and color pl. 5. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1673, $1,250. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 9/7/67. Ex-coll: James P. McGowan. Note: An important plate with impeccable provenance and in top condition. Lot 2364 - LEE/ROSE NO. 650 , pale blue, plain rope rim, top and bottom. Extremely rare. New England, possibly New England Glass Co. 3 11/16" d. Virtually proof having only two minute flakes to outer rim and several flakes under rim, profile is proof, slight under-rim fin. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1674. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 174, fig. 30, "100 Best" colored. Parallels Spillman, fig. 442. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/69, $300. Lot 2365 - LEE/ROSE NO. 651-A , colorless with small green streak, plain rim. Extremely rare. Philadelphia area. 3 1/4" d. Proof except for a small under-rim spall and a light underfill, profile is proof. Estimate: $300 - $500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1675. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 174, fig. 31, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: James H. Rose, 10/72, $250. Lot 2366 - LEE/ROSE NO. 653 , colorless with all-over frosted/cloudy surface, plain rim. Extremely rare. Uncertain origin, possibly Midwestern. 3" d. Moderate top-rim flaking/mold roughness, profile is virtually proof, two flakes to table ring. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Bilane, p. 35. Elsholz, lot #1676. Note: Rose noted "The few specimens of this plate we have seen have been cloudy and sick." An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #661) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear. Lot 2367 - LEE/ROSE NO. 654 , colorless with a hint of cloudiness, plain rim. Extremely rare. Uncertain origin, probably Midwestern. 3" d. Near proof having only some minor top-rim flakes. Estimate: $400 - $600. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1677. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #662) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2368 - LEE/ROSE NO. 654-A , colorless, plain rope rim, top only. Very rare. Probably Midwestern. 3" d. Proof except for a minute top-rim flake and an area of under-rim mold roughness. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Bilane, p. 35. Elsholz, lot #1678. Innes, pl. 314. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/69, $55. Lot 2369 - LEE/ROSE NO. 655 , colorless, with an all-over pebbly surface, 30 even scallops, shorter feet. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/16" d. Proof with a very light underfill. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1701. Spillman, fig. 443. Provenance: Guernsey, 10/69. Lot 2370 - LEE/ROSE NO. 656 , colorless, 30 even scallops, shorter feet. Very rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/16" d. Near proof, one lightly tipped scallop, one minor top-rim flake, and a small under-rim spall. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1702. Spillman, fig. 444. Innes, pl. 314. Provenance: Guernsey, 10/69. Lot 2371 - LEE/ROSE NO. 658 , brilliant emerald green, 78 even scallops. Extremely rare. Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Rim chip erasing three scallops, loss of two additional scallops, and several others tipped or lightly tipped. Estimate: $400 - $600. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1740. B & K I, fig. 1426. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 180, fig. 7, "100 Best" colored. . Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #605) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2372 - LEE/ROSE NO. 661 , brilliant medium blue with opalescent overcast, 79 even scallops. Unrecorded in AGCP, Bilane reported this and one other example. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Near proof having only one tipped and two lightly tipped scallops. Estimate: $1,500 - $2,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1741, this being the actual example. Bilane, p. 35. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1741, $1,100. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 6/11/63. Note: An important and beautiful plate with impeccable provenance and in top condition. Lot 2373 - LEE/ROSE NO. 662 , light opalescent, 79 even scallops. Very rare. Probably Boston & Sandwich Glass Co. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for a single tipped scallop, slightly out of round. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1705, this being the actual example. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 186, fig. 1, "100 Best" colored. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1705, $225. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 8/31/55. Ex-coll: Paul Carson. Lot 2374 - LEE/ROSE NO. 669 , colorless, 36 bull's-eye scallops. Extremely rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 3/8" d. Poor condition which is normal for this plate (see note), loss of two scallops and another bull's eye, otherwise only some light tipping and mold roughness. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1711, this being the actual example. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 12/28/00, lot #57, $750. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1711, $625. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/9/67. James H. Rose, agent. Ex-coll: John Rollin Stuart, III. Note: An important plate despite its condition issues. Rose noted "It is extremely rare (we know of but about five specimens) and all examples we have seen are in very bad condition." Marble's specimen, which is illustrated in AGCP, is also missing multiple scallops. The Marble example was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #668) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2375 - LEE/ROSE NO. 670-A , cloudy soft light to medium blue, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Extremely rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Near proof for this rim having only one tipped scallop with corresponding loss of under-rim bull's eye and very minor flaking/mold roughness. Large piece of undissolved metal at shoulder with two short radiating refractions as made. Estimate: $500 - $800. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1742, this being the actual example. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 180, fig. 2, "100 Best" colored. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1742, $1,000. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 4/2/60. Ex-coll: Ernest W. Young. Note: An important plate with impeccable provenance for which we could locate no additional sales records. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #610) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list where he noted "apparently unique in this lighter shade." Lot 2376 - LEE/ROSE NO. 670-B , colorless, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Uncertain rarity, probably rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Well above average condition, one scallop lightly tipped and two others very lightly tipped, five points lightly tipped, along with a few minor top-rim flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Green Valley Auctions, Inc., 4/30/04, lot #319, $99. Ex-coll: John E. Bilane. James H. Rose, 5/70, $20. Lot 2377 - LEE/ROSE NO. 670-C , colorless, 42 even scallops. Rare. Midwestern. 3" d. Virtually proof for this plate having only one lightly tipped scallop. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1713. Provenance: Guernsey, 10/69. Note: Rose noted "We have never seen a proof specimen and most of them are badly battered." Lot 2378 - LEE/ROSE NO. 671 , opalescent tint, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Rare. Midwestern. 3 1/2" d. Loss of two scallops and corresponding point, otherwise only some very light tipping/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Abraham & May, 3/69, $20. Lot 2379 - LEE/ROSE NO. 673 , colorless, 60 even scallops. Very rare. Midwestern. 3 1/8" d. Near proof having only one tipped scallop and a small top-rim chip. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1793. Provenance: James H. Rose, 6/72, $65. Lot 2380 - LEE/ROSE NO. 676-B , deep cobalt blue, embossed "Fort Pitt", 20 large scallops with small scallop between. Very rare. Curling's Ft. Pitt Glass Works. 3 11/16" d. Well above average condition, one small scallop tipped, some light top-rim flaking/mold roughness, mold roughness to table ring, light inner-rim wear. Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1743. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 180, fig. 3, "100 Best" colored. Spillman, fig. 451 and color pl. 6. Innes, dust jacket and color pl. 6, "It is very rare in this beautiful dark blue". Provenance: Abraham & May, 9/73, $350. Lot 2381 - LEE/ROSE NO. 677-A , blue, 44 even scallops. Rare. Midwestern. 3 3/16" d. Proof with a couple minute rim nicks. Estimate: $300 - $500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1744. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 180, fig. 16, "100 Best" colored. Provenance: Dorothy Neal, 1974, $150. Lot 2382 - LEE/ROSE NO. 677-E , colorless, octagonal with six even scallops between corners. Extremely rare. Midwestern. 3 7/16" d. Near proof for this plate, one corner scallop tipped and another very lightly tipped, two small rim spalls and a few light top-rim flakes. Estimate: $200 - $300. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1801. Provenance: Green Valley Auctions, Inc., 5/19/06, lot #633, $198. Note: Rose noted "Not only is this plate of extraordinary rarity but, as in all octagonal plates, proof specimens are nearly unobtainable." Lot 2383 - LEE/ROSE NO. 677-F , colorless, octagonal with six even scallops between corners. Very rare. Midwestern. 3 7/16" d. Near proof having only one lightly tipped corner scallop and a few light top-rim flakes. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1803. Provenance: Abraham & May, 7/75, $100. Note: This is the first example of this plate that we have sold. Lot 2384 - LEE/ROSE NO. 677-G , colorless, octagonal with six even scallops between corners. Very rare. Midwestern. 3 7/16" d. Above average condition with two corner and several side scallops lightly tipped. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1802. Provenance: Richard H. Wood, 8/69, $85. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #667) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2385 - LEE/ROSE NO. 677-H , colorless, octagonal with six even scallops between corners. Extremely rare. Midwestern. 3 3/8" d. Loss of one corner scallop, three side scallops tipped, some light top-rim flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Bilane, p. 36, "I know of but three." Provenance: James H. Rose, 10/72, $100. Lot 2386 - LEE/ROSE NO. 678 , colorless with pink moonstone tint, 42 even scallops. Very rare, possibly extremely rare. Midwestern. 3 1/4" d. Well above average condition, one scallop tipped, three adjacent small top-rim spalls and several flakes. Estimate: $75 - $125. Provenance: James H. Rose, 11/69, $25. Note: Rose noted "We have never seen a proof example" and "Even badly battered examples are not common". Lot 2387 - LEE/ROSE NO. 678 , colorless, 42 even scallops. Very rare. Midwestern. 3 1/4" d. Above average condition, three scallops tipped and several others lightly tipped, several very light top-rim flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1804. Note: Rose noted "We have never seen a proof example" and "Even badly battered examples are not common." Lot 2388 - LEE/ROSE NO. 680 , brilliant lilac, 44 even scallops. Very rare. Probably Midwestern. 3" d. Three scallops tipped and three others lightly tipped, three light top-rim flakes and minor mold roughness. Estimate: $500 - $800. Reference: Bilane, p. 36. Provenance: Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Lot 2389 - LEE/ROSE NO. 680 , blue, 44 even scallops. Very rare. Probably Midwestern. 3" d. Three scallops tipped and another very lightly tipped, otherwise proof. Estimate: $200 - $300. Provenance: James H. Rose, 1968, $65. Lot 2390 - LEE/ROSE NO. 680-C , colorless, very thick example, 45 bull's-eye scallops. Very rare. Probably Midwestern. 3 1/4" d. Rim spall removing the top of one scallop but leaving the bull's eye intact, several other light rim spalls, four scallops very lightly tipped, along with some light mold roughness. Estimate: $75 - $125. Reference: Bilane, p. 36. Provenance: Green Valley Auctions, Inc., 4/30/04, lot #332, $143. Ex-coll: John E. Bilane. Kermit Hathaway, 11/86, $44. Lot 2391 - LEE/ROSE NO. 685 , colorless with a hint of cloudiness, embossed "New Patent Steam Coach", plain rim with alternating small and large rib outer edge. Extremely rare, Elsholz's notes reveal only six known. Possibly Midwestern. 3 5/8" d. Excellent condition, shallow top-rim chip and light flaking/mold roughness, heavy partial rim fin with small chips. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1807, this being the actual example. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 172, fig. 18, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1807, $4,100. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 3/28/68. Ex-coll: Louise S. Esterly. Ex-coll: Mrs. Harry S. High. Note: An extremely important and desirable plate with impeccable provenance. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #652) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2392 - LEE/ROSE NO. 686 , colorless, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Near proof for this rim, one tipped scallop and point, one lightly tipped scallop, and just a hint of mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1830. Spillman, fig. 459. Innes, pl. 312. Provenance: James H. Rose, 9/68, $45. Lot 2393 - LEE/ROSE NO. 686 , blue, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Extremely rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Two moderate and three small top-rim spalls, several tipped scallops and points. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1748. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 182, fig. 33, "100 Best" colored. Spillman, fig. 458 and color pl. 6. Provenance: Sue Williamson, 6/75, $135. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 37, #615) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" colored list. Lot 2394 - LEE/ROSE NO. 689-X-1 , colorless, variant with large 4mm bull's eyes, 24 bull's-eye scallops with single point between. Very rare. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 7/16" d. Loss of one scallop and point, otherwise only some minor flaking/mold roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1831. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 171, fig. 7, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Abraham & May, 3/69, $50. Lot 2395 - LEE/ROSE NO. 689-A , colorless, octagonal with seven even scallops between each corner. Extremely rare, only six recorded. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/2" d. Proof except for a very light small top-rim spall. Estimate: $1,500 - $2,500. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1832, this being the actual example. Provenance: Collector's Sales & Service, 4/11/95, lot #113, $3,025. Ex-coll: Gladys & Paul Richards. Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 11/18/87, lot #1832, $950. Ex-coll: William J. Elsholz. James H. Rose, 1/16/57. Note: A very important plate with impeccable provenance and in the best possible condition. An example from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #671) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2396 - LEE/ROSE NO. 690 , colorless, 30 even scallops. Extremely rare, only eight or nine recorded. Midwestern, probably Pittsburgh. 3 1/8" d. Above average condition, two scallops tipped and two others lightly tipped, one small under-rim chip and several flakes. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1833. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 176, fig. 62, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: James H. Rose, 1970, $150. Note: An example of this plate from the Marble collection was included in the 1954 Corning exhibit (case 38, #669) and included by Rose in his new "100 Best" clear list. Lot 2397 - LEE/ROSE NO. 691 , colorless, 24 large beads with reels between. Scarce. Probably Midwestern. 3 3/16" d. Proof except for a few minute top-rim flakes. Estimate: $50 - $75. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1834. Spillman, fig. 460. Innes, pl. 312. Provenance: Maloney, 12/71, $10. Note: Rose noted "Really proof examples are almost impossible to find". Lot 2398 - LEE/ROSE NO. 691-A , colorless, 42 even scallops. Extremely rare. Probably Midwestern. 3" d. Above average condition, two scallops tipped and several others very lightly tipped, several small top-rim spalls. Estimate: $100 - $150. Reference: Elsholz, lot #1835. McKearin Am. Glass, pl. 176, fig. 64, "100 Best" clear. Provenance: Richard A. Bourne Co., Inc., 5/18/74, lot #454, $70. Ex-coll: Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth D. Wakefield. Note: Rose noted "We can trace but ten of these plates". Lot 2399 - LEE/ROSE NO. 694-A , colorless, 42 even scallops. Scarce. Probably Midwestern. 3" d. Proof except for one lightly tipped scallop. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: Arman Absentee Auctions, 4/19/89, lot #245, $11. Ex-coll: Yaeger Family. Note: Rose noted "Most examples are found in rather ragged condition". Lot 2400 - LEE/ROSE NO. 828 TODDY PLATE, blue, 40 even scallops. Very or extremely rare. Unknown origin. 4 7/8" d. Near proof having only a few small light top-rim flakes and minor roughness to a heavy under-rim fin. Estimate: $100 - $150. Lot 2401 - LEE/ROSE NO. 842 SULPHIDE , colorless, Classic Napoleon bust facing right, 15 scallops with shelves, top-rim beads, hanger hole. European. 3 5/16" d. Above average condition, one scallop lightly tipped, small top-rim chip/bruise, two small under-rim chips and light mold roughness. Estimate: $200 - $300. Lot 2402 - LEE/ROSE NO. 842 SULPHIDE , colorless, unidentified bust facing left, 15 scallops with shelves, top-rim beads, hanger hole. European. 3 5/16" d. Near proof having only a minute top-rim chip, one small under-rim chip and very minor mold roughness. Estimate: $200 - $300. Provenance: Abraham & May, 3/69, $75. Lot 2403 - LEE/ROSE NO. 842 SULPHIDE , colorless, crucifixion of Christ, 15 scallops with shelves, top-rim beads, hanger hole. European. 3 5/16" d. Average condition, one scallop tipped, several top-rim and under-rim chips, along with normal mold roughness. Estimate: $100 - $150. Lot 2404 - LEE/ROSE NO. 843 SULPHIDE , colorless, Louis Philippe bust facing left, 15 scallops with shelves, hanger hole, factory polished front. European. 3 5/16" d. Poor condition, large rim chip and spall, along with smaller chips and roughness. Estimate: $50 - $75. Provenance: London, 1975, $50. Lot 2405 - UNLISTED CUP PLATE, colorless, 40 even scallops, plumes around a sparsely stippled shoulder, all-over diamond center, no resonance. Probably very rare. Unknown origin. 3 3/4" d. Undamaged except for a shallow chip and two flakes to table ring. Estimate: $100 - $150. Provenance: Green Valley Auctions, Inc., 4/30/05, lot #956, $275. Ex coll: Mary Myers Parker.